The Gamut of Ascertaining Better Title with Recourse to the Nemo Dat Principle -By Caroline Ladidi Anze-Bishop NEC Rep NBA Bukuru Branch
In the bid to determine the person with better title, a Court can well nullify spurious and fraudulent documents presented by a party in dispute. See IBE vs. OKONKWO & ANOR.(2020)LCN/14126(CA)
CONTINUE READING THIS ARTICLE BELOW AFTER THESE IMPORTANT NOTICES
Log in to primsol.lawpavilion.com and store.lawpavilion.com to enjoy the best E-journals, textbooks, and many more. For further enquiries/assistance, send an email to customercare@lawpavilion.com or call 08050298729
ISSUE: EQUITABLE INTEREST IN LAND-Whether an equitable owner in possession can be overridden by a subsequent grantee of a legal estate(Issue is mine)
PRINCIPLE:
“Now on page 489 last paragraph, the learned trial Judge held as follows: “The question now arises as to whether there was any interest to transfer to the Defendant at the time of sale, whether legal or equitable. The question must be asked whether by this date, in March, 2008, the vendor had any title retained by him or reclaimed by him. The issue is that at this date March, 2008, the Donor on record, Dr. Wen Musa Ibrahim no longer had any legal interest and therefore the Irrevocable Power of Attorney between him and Mr. Ibe Chjioke Christopher is hereby null and void and of no effect.”
The trial Judge according to the learned Counsel to the Appellant had no materials or evidence before him to have made such pronouncement in that the onus was squarely on Respondents and not on the Appellant to establish the claim to declaratory reliefs.
It is true and trite that the Plaintiff in a case for declaration of title to land must rely on the strength of his own case and not on the weakness of the defence, There is an exception to the general principle of law relating to burden or onus of proof in a claim for declaration of title to land. See:-
1. MR AUDU OTUKPO V. APA JOHN & ANOR. (2012) 7 NWLR (PART 1299) 357 AT 376 H – 377A per ONNOGHEN, JSC, who said:- “It is settled law that a Plaintiff in an action for declaration of title to land must succeed on the strength of his case and not on the weakness of the defence though where the case of the defence support that of the Plaintiff, the Plaintiff can take advantage of same in establishing his claim. See Woluchem V. Gudi (1981) 5 SC 294; Mogaji V. Cadbury Nig. Ltd. (1985) 2 NWLR (Pt. 7) 393.”
2. NELSON NWOSU ONWUGBUFOR & ORS. V. HERBERT OKOYE & ORS. (1996) per IGUH, JSC, who said: “It must however be emphasized that the applicable principle is that a Plaintiff when claiming declaration of title must succeed on the strength of his own case and not on the weakness of the defence although where any aspect of the defendant’s case supports the Plaintiff’s case, the plaintiff will not be deprived of the advantage of such support. See Kodilinye V. Mbanefo Odu 2 WACA 336 at 337; Cobblah V. Gbeke 12 WACA 294; Akinola V. Oluwo (1962) 1 All NLR 224 At Page 225; Nwogbogu V. Chief Nnoli Ibeziako (1972) 1 All NLR (Pt. 2) 137.”
3. KABURU PADA V. WOYA GALADIMA & ANOR. (2018) 3 NWLR (PART 1607) 436 AT 456 per SANUSI, JSC, who said: “It is noted by me, that both lower Courts have found that the identity of the land in dispute was not in controversy. It is equally on established law that in a claim of declaration of title to land, a plaintiff has the onus to prove his case based on the evidence he adduces at the trial and not to rely or capitalise on the weakness(es) in the defendant’s case even though he can always take advantage of the evidence of the defence which supports his case. See Tukuru V. Sabi (2005) 3 NWLR (Pt. 913) 544; Ojo V. Anibire (1999) 11 NWLR (Pt. 628) 630. See also Uchendu V. Ogboni (1999) 4 Sc (Pt. II) 1; (1999) 3 NWLR (Pt. 603) 337 and Akinola V. Oluwo (1962) 1 SCNLR 352.”
4. ALHAJI WAHAB ARIJE V. MUSTAPHA ARIJE & ORS. (2018) 16 NWLR (PART 1644) 67 AT 88D – E per KEKERE-EKUN, JSC, who said: “The law is settled, as rightly submitted by learned counsel for the appellant, that a claim for declaration of title may be proved in anyone of the following ways:
1. By traditional evidence;
2. By production of documents of title duly authenticated and executed.
3. By acts of ownership extending over a sufficient length of time numerous and positive enough as to warrant the inference of true ownership.
4. By acts of long possession and enjoyment.
5. By acts of possession of connected or adjacent land in circumstances rendering it probable that the owner of such adjacent or connected land would in addition be the owner of the land in dispute. Idundun V. Okumagba (1976) 9 – 10 SC 227 @ 246; Nkado V. Obiano (1997) 5 SCNJ 33 @ 47, (1997) 5 NWLR (Pt. 503) 31; Owhonda V. Ekpechi (2003) 9 – 11 SCNJ 1 @ 6, (2003) 17 NWLR (Pt. 849) 326. It is equally trite that the onus is on the claimant to establish his title upon a preponderance of the evidence or on the balance of probability. He must succeed on the strength of his own case and not on the weakness of the defence, except where the defendant’ case supports his case. See Kodilinye V. Odu (1935) 2 WACA 336 @ 357; Onwugbufor V. Okoye (1996) 1 NWLR (Pt. 424) 252; Shittu V. Fashawe (2005) 7 SC (Pt. 11) 107, (2005) 14 NWLR (Pt. 946) 671; Nruamah & Ors. V. Ebuzoeme & Ors. (2013) 1 SC 31 @ 55-56, (2013) 13 NWLR (Pt. 1372) 474.”
The parties to this appeal agreed that the property in dispute was originally allocated to one DR. MUSA WEN IBRAHIM in 2002 and that MR. MAXIMUS OLIOBI was his Attorney or Agent. The avowed position of the 1st Respondent was that MAXIMUS OLIOBI purchased the property IN DISPUTE Plot 1360 situate at GUDU DISTRICT, ABUJA sometime in 2004. The Respondents pleaded in paragraphs 6 and 7 of the Further Amended Statement of Claim that all documents relating to the sale and transfer of the property were handed over to MAXIMUS OLIOBI by DR. MUSA WEN IBRAHIM and that the said MAXIMUS OLIOBI took all necessary steps to effect change of ownership and transfer of the land to himself at the ABUJA GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEMS FCT ADMINISTRATION. That the documents relating to the land in dispute got lost and MAXIMUS OBI the predecessor-in-title of the 1st Respondent enlisted the services of BARRISTER CHUKWUEMEKA EZE (DW1) of IVORY CHAMBERS, Legal Practitioners and Consultants, Abuja, to pursue the registration of title to the land in dispute in favour of MAXIMUS OLIOBI in October 2007. The history of sale of the land by MAXIMUS OLIOBI to 1st Respondent and later to 2nd Respondent as per the evidence of Plaintiffs witnesses at the trial was amply captured on pages 12 – 16 of the Respondents’ Brief of Argument.
The entire case of the Appellant at the trial was tied to and dependent on the role played by the aforesaid Chukwuemeka Eze (DW1) who apart from acting for the predecessor-in-title of the 1st Respondent also found it convenient in 2008 to be the Agent of the Appellant for the negotiation of sale of the land in dispute to Appellant knowing fully well that he had in 2007 written a letter Exhibit “L” on behalf of MAXIMUS OLIOBI as the owner of the property in dispute the said MAXIMUS OLIOBI having purchased same in 2004 from the original allottee DR. MUSA WEN IBRAHIM. The Appellant’s case also rested primarily on the evidence of Barrister Chukwuemeka Eze who testified for Appellant as DW1. The evidence of Appellant (DW2) was about all he was told concerning the land by DW1, Chukwuemeka Eze, Esq.
The case of the Respondents is clearly a claim to prior equitable interest in the land in dispute found on the fact that the person with the legal estate in the property DR. MUSA WEN IBRAHIM had in 2004 sold the entire interest or right of occupancy to MAXIMUS OLIOBI who sold the land to the 1st Respondent for valuable consideration in January, 2008. It was the position of the Respondent that as at 13th March, 2008 when the original allottee purported to sell the said land to the Appellant he had nothing to sell to the Appellant on the maxim of NEMO DAT QUOD NON HABET. The transfer of the land and vesting of same in MAXIMUS OLIOBI was with the knowledge and active participation of Barrister Chukwuemeka Eze. The same Chukwuemeka spearheaded and participated in the purported sole of the land in dispute to the Appellant over five years after the land was sold to MAXIMUS OLIOBI who sold the land to 1st Respondent in January 2008 to the knowledge of Barr. Chukwuemeka Eze who testified as DW1 for Appellant at the trial.
In order to bring to the fore the eminent facts showing that the land was sold to MAXIMUS OLIOBI by DR. WEN MUSA IBRAHIM who purportedly transferred the land to Appellant vide Exhibit “P” the alleged Irrevocable Power of Attorney made in favour of Appellant on 13/3/2008 three months after 1st Respondent had acquired equitable interest in the property it is necessary to reproduce in full Exhibit “L” written by Barr. Chukwuemeka Eze who testified for the Appellant as DW1. The letter/document Exhibit “L” reads:-
“October 22, 2007
The Director
Abuja Geographic Information Systems
Abuja
Sir,
SAVE OUR SOUL
RE-FILE NO NS 354 PLOT 1360 GUDU DISTRICT RECERTIFICATION OF TITLE DOCUMENTS
We act as solicitors to Maximus Oliobi and have his instructions to write you.
Our client acquired the above property sometimes in 2004.
Before they could register their Interests on the property, the file got missing thereby halting the registration of their interests.
It was during the period of search for the file that the Honourable Minister directed that all Title documents holders should recertify them.
When the registration of our client’s interest became thorny they were advised to pay the mandatory fees for recertification and a temporary file opened for the processing of the his (sic) documents.
Copies of the receipts of payment for the registration of power of attorney and recertification fees are hereby attached.
Our client was also further advised to cause to be advertised in 3 national dailies the loss of his right of occupancy. The copies of the advertisement in the 3 Newspapers and the affidavits and police reports are hereby attached.
He also submitted the copies of his documents for temporary recertification.
However, after persistent visit to get the power of attorney registered and get document from your organization showing that he had complied with the re- certification process he has cause to believe that there is deliberate attempt contrived to deprive him of his plot.
This is more so as the development control department have refused to process his drawings for approval on the ostensible reason that he could not provide any acknowledgement from AGIS showing that he re-certified his documents. We therefore urge that in the light of above circumstance, of which we have no control, to appeal that you do the processing of recertification in the name of our client MAXIMUS OLIOBI who will then pay the attendant regulation fee.
We look forward to your prompt and effective response to our plight.
Thanks
Yours faithfully
For IVORY CHAMBERS
CHUKWUEMEKA EZE, ESQ.”
There is no doubt that the Appellant and his Agent Chukwuemeka, Esq. who incidentally was also Agent of MAXIMUS OLIOBI who sold the land to 1st Respondent earlier in time knew and are deemed to have NOTICE that the land in dispute belonged to MAXIMUS OLIOBI since 2004 when he bought the same from the original and legal owner DR. MUSA WEN IBRAHIM. In effect as at 13/3/2008 when he purportedly gave Irrevocable Power of Attorney to the Appellant, DR. MUSA WEN IBRAHIM had already divested himself and fully disposed his interest in the land to MAXIMUS OLIOBI as could be seen in Exhibit “L” written by the DW1 on behalf of the said MAXIMUS OLIOBI. Barrister Chukwuemeka Eze acted for the Appellant. He had knowledge of the sale to MAXIMUS OLIOBI while he wrote Exhibit “L” in IVORY CHAMBERS and signed the letter as acting for MAXIMUS OLIOBI way back in October, 22, 2007. Notwithstanding that he claimed that he wrote the letter on the instruction of his principal. The fact remains that he had knowledge of the earlier purchase of the land by MAXIMUS OLIOBI from DR. MUSA WEN IBRAHIM. The Appellant is bound by the Notice and knowledge of an earlier sale of the land all known to his Agent Chukwuemeka Eze. See:
1. ALHAJA JURADAT ANIMASHAUN V. G. A. OLOJO (1990) LPELR – 491 (SC) where the Supreme Court per OBASEKI, JSC, said on pages 17 – 19 thus:- “What is the meaning of a ‘bona fide’ purchaser of the legal estate for value without notice?’
Bona fide:
‘Bona fide’ is defined as “In good faith, honestly, without fraud, collusion, or participation In wrong doing.”
Purchaser for value:
‘Purchaser’ in its technical sense does not necessarily imply purchaser for value. ‘For value’ are included to show that value must be given to earn the immunity from equitable claimants. Value means any consideration in money, money’s worth (e.g. other lands, stocks and shores or services or marriage. (See Le Neve V. Le Neve (1747) 1 Ves Sen 64: Wh & T. 157 Willoughby loughby V. Willoughby 1 TR. 763.
Of a Legal estate:
As Courts of equity break in upon the common law, when necessity and conscience require it, still they allow superior force and strength to a legal title to estate.
See Wortley V. Birkhead (1754)2 Ves Sen 571 at 574 per Lord Hardwicke, LC.
Without Notice:
He must have no notice of the existence of equitable interest. He must have neither actual notice nor constructive notice nor imputed notice.
A person has actual notice of all facts of which he has (or has had) actual knowledge however that knowledge was acquired.
Constructive Notice:
The Court of Chancery insisted that purchaser should inquire about equitable interests with no less diligence that about legal interest which they could ignore only at their own peril. The motto of English conveyance is caveat emptor; the risk of encumbrances is on the purchaser who must satisfy himself by a full investigation of title before completing his purchase. A purchaser would be able to plead absence of notice only if he had made all usual and proper inquires, and had still found nothing to indicate the equitable interest.
In the instant appeal, if the appellant had visited the site of the land, plot 27 before completing the purchase, she would have found that the respondent was already in possession of the land and then further enquires would have revealed that her vendors had already sold the plot and collected the purchase price from the respondent.
Imputed Notice:
There is a third category of notice known as imputed notice. If a purchaser employs an agent, such as a solicitor, any actual or constructive notice (Re Aims Corn Charity (1901) 2 Ch. 750) which the agent receives imputed to the purchaser. There is no evidence that any agent acted for the appellant.
Since plot 27 was already sold to the defendant/respondent and who was put in possession before the appellate bought and received the conveyance Exhibit A assuming that the plan attached to Exhibit A correctly describes the property, she bought subject to the equitable interests in the land acquired by the respondent.
In view of all I have said above, I found no merit In the appeal and for the above reasons. I dismissed the appeal and affirmed the decision of the Court of Appeal.”
(Underlined mine)
2. DR. BENJAMIN OHIAERI V. ALHAJI B. I. YUSSUF & ORS (2009) LPELR – 2361 SC 1 AT 20 – 22 per TABAI, JSC, who said: “Thus even if it is accepted that the 3rd respondent sold the property evidenced in exhibit “A” without the consent or concurrence of the 4th respondent, it remains a valid sale variable only at the instance of the said 4th respondent. I hold on conclusion therefore that exhibit “A” remains a valid agreement of sale of the land in dispute and which has created an equitable interest in favour of the 2nd respondent and which equitable interest ranks as high as and can even supersede a subsequent legal estate created in favour of another person over the same land. The next question is that of determining the priority of the equities as between the 2nd respondent and the appellant. The appellant claims to have acquired his lead estate over the property for value and without notice of the 2nd respondent’s equitable interest thereon. The settled principle is that only a subsequent bonafide purchaser of a legal estate for value without notice that can take priority over someone who had acquired a prior equitable interest over the some property. This is the principle in Animashaun V. Olojo (1990) 6 NWLR (Pt. 154) 111 at 121.
There is no gainsaying the fact that the appellant bought the property for value. The evidence is that he paid N1,000,000.00 to the same 3rd respondent. But can he be said to have bought the property bonafide and without notice. In Animashun V. Olojo (supra) purchase “without notice” was explained to mean that the purchaser must have no notice of the existence of the equitable interest, that is, that he must have neither actual notice, nor constructive notice, nor imputed notice. It was also held that if the purchaser employs an agent such as a solicitor, any actual or constructive notice which the agent receives is imputed to the purchaser.
In this case the uncontroverted evidence is that the same Chief Ladi Williams who brought the 2nd and 3rd respondent together and indeed facilitated the sale of the property to the 2nd respondent was also the agent of the appellant and facilitated the conveyance of the property by the 3rd and 4th respondents to the appellant. Therefore the notice actual or constructive of the prior equitable interest by Chief Ladi Williams is imputed to the appellant. On this issue, the learned trial Judge in his judgment at page 231 of the record had this to say: “In spite of the search conducted at the Land Registry at the instance of the 3rd defendant, no encumbrance was found, yet the knowledge of the earlier sale to the plaintiffs’ is impliedly imputed to the 3rd defendant through the role of Chief Rotimi Williams Chambers.”
I think I have every cause to endorse the above reasoning and conclusion. The knowledge of Chief Ladi Williams and indeed Chief Rotimi Williams Chamber about the prior sale to the 2nd plaintiff/respondent is, in law, imputed to the appellant. The result is that he cannot claim protection under the doctrine of innocent purchaser for value without notice. He had notice or notice imputed to him and so the defence does not avail him. In view of the foregoing considerations therefore I resolve the first issue in favour of the respondent.
With respect to the 2nd issue of whether the agreement for sale between the 3rd respondent and the plaintiff/respondent can found an action in specific performance, the answer, in my view is again in the affirmative. An action for specific performance arise once there exists a contract coupled with circumstances which make it equitable to grant a decree of same. This being a contract for the sale of land attracts a greater justification for a decree of specific performance because as opposed to other types of contract, the land may have a special and peculiar value to the purchaser. The plaintiffs/ respondents have therefore every justification to claim for specific performance. With respect to the 3rd respondent, she must do equity for “equity looks on that as done which ought to be done”. Put In another way, equity imputes on her an intention to fulfill an obligation and the obligation is for her to specifically perform. The result is that I also resolve the 2nd issue in favour of the respondents.
On the whole I do not fancy any reason to disturb the decision of the two Courts below which I therefore affirm. This appeal stands dismissed and is accordingly dismissed for lack of merit. I assess the costs of this appeal at N50,000.00 in favour of the plaintiffs/respondents.” (Underlined mine)
I agree with the finding of the learned trial Judge on pages 490 – 491 of the record of appeal where he found as follows: “The Defendant, who engaged Barrister Eze claiming him as his agent, clearly had notice of the existence of the interest of Mr. Oliobi and the other Plaintiffs generally, and cannot be said to be an innocent purchaser for value. Since in his examination in chief, he stated that he never went to AGIS and stated that it was Barrister Eze who conducted the search and later told him that there was not caveat on the land with the land being genuine. He also stated that it was Barrister Eze his lawyer, who helped in recertifying the documents at AGIS. From this, it can be deduced that there could not be a registered interest for Oliobi at the time of this search, for the simple reason that it is same Barrister Eze was in process, or rather was under a legal duty to process the Certified True Copies of Letter of Allocation, Power of Attorney, Sales Agreement for Mr. Oliobi. This processing had to be completed first before any other interest, apart from the original allottee could be registered.
So, Barrister Eze who was formerly in the middle of both parties was under a solemn duty as an agent to both, and especially as a legal practitioner to have informed the Defendant of the Plaintiffs interest. To have kept quiet, withdrawn his brief from Oliobi, and to have swapped parties was most unprofessional and extremely distasteful and totally unbecoming.
The most persuasive evidence which corroborated the Plaintiff is actually a document written by the defence witness No. 2. In it, he announced that he was acting for Maximus Oliobi, and further stated that the said Oliobi had acquired the property sometime in 2004. He also confirmed the loss of the file by stating that fact in this letter, and attributed this loss to be the reason for halting the registration of their interest. There is also evidence adduced in this letter that they paid for the registration of the Power of Attorney and recertification fees and advertised in the Newspapers and referred to the Police Report and affidavits. The letter revealed that PW4 had attempted to get his development plan but was stalled because he could not provide the acknowledgment from AGIS of recertification. He also confirmed the PW4 as settling the local inhabitants and finally directed the processing of the re-certification in the name of MAXIMUS OLIOBI. He annexed the copies of the AGIS receipts for the Power of Attorney and Recertification and the newspaper clippings.
The Court is satisfied that the Plaintiff has indeed proven their entitlement to the land based on their equitable interest and their acquisition was legal. The fact of the loss of title documents is not the fact that they never existed. The Plaintiffs have proved the fact that they were in possession and also proved a superior right to possession over the defendant.”
There is no doubt that the Respondents actually led credible evidence and produced relevant documentary evidence with probative value showing that the Respondents acquired valid equitable interest in the property in dispute ever before the Appellant purportedly acquired interest in the property. The Appellant was/is fully aware of the prior interest of the Respondents in the land Plot 1360 Gudu District Abuja. The mere fact of Registration of the purported Power of Attorney Exhibit “P” spuriously and fraudulently made in his favour cannot under any guise defeat the prior interest of the Respondents and their predecessor in title MAXIMUS OLIOBI. The said Irrevocable Power of Attorney given by DR. MUSA IBRAHIM to MR. IBE CHIJIOKE CHRISTOPHER is a fluke and it is null and void. As at the time he gave out the purported Power of Attorney he has no scintilla of interest, legal or equitable in the said Plot 1360 Gudu District Abuja again having sold same to MAXIMUS OLIOBI in 2004. The lower Court was perfectly in order in nullifying Exhibit “P” and vacating its unlawful or illegal effect. Exhibit “P” does not exist in the eyes of the law. See:-
1. NAPOLEON S. ORIANZI V. THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL RIVERS STATE & ORS. (2017) 6 NWLR (PT. 1561) 224 AT 273 C – H per GALINJE, JSC, who said: “In Olukoya V. Ashiru (2006) All FWLR (Pt. 322) 1479 at 1514 paras, E-H, (2006) 11 NWLR (Pt. 990) 1, this Court held that an equitable owner in possession cannot be overridden by a subsequent grantee of a legal estate. This is what my brother, Ogbuagu, JSC, 38, paras. F-H who read the lead judgment said: “As rightly submitted in the respondent’s brief at page 8, the Jalingo Local government having lawfully granted the land in dispute to the respondent, in 1981, it was left with nothing to grant to the appellant subsequently in 1983 during the subsistence of the grant to the respondent… so that, if there is proof that money was paid for the land coupled with an entry into possession it is sufficient, to defeat the title of a subsequent purchaser of the legal estate, if and provided that the possession, is continuously maintained… Thus, if even it is coupled with possession, it cannot be overridden by a legal estate”. See Ogbu & 4 Ors. V. Ani & Ors. (1994) 78 SCNJ (Pt. II) 363, (1994) 7 NWLR (Pt. 335) 128; Soremekun V. Shodipo (1959) LLR 30; Orasanmi V. Idowu (1959) 4 FSC 40, (1959) SCNLR 97; Oshodi V. Balogun & Ors. (1934) 4 WACA 1.
Clearly the right of occupancy available to the appellant over the disputed property was not automatically extinguished by Section 5(2) of the Land Use Act by the purported sale and subsequent grant of a statutory right of occupancy over the same property to the 3rd and 4th respondents. To allow such an injustice, is to allow those in authority to benefit from their wrong actions. Rivers State Government cannot determine a contract in which it is a party and then take certain benefit arising therefrom leaving the party aggrieved without any remedy.”
At page 284 C – G, AUGIE, JSC, said as follows: “In Tewogbade V. Obadina (1994) 4 NWLR (Pt. 338) 326 at pp. 347-348 paras. H-A this Court per Iguh, JSC, hit the nail right on the head, as follows: “Where two contesting parties trace their title in respect of the same piece of land to the same grantor, the applicable principle of law has always been that the latter in time of the two parties to obtain the grant cannot maintain an action against the party who first obtained a valid grant of the land from such a common grantor. The reason is obvious as a grantor having successfully divested himself of his title in respect of the disputed piece or parcel of land by the first grant would have nothing left to convey to a subsequent purchaser under the elementary principle of nemo dot quod non habet as no one may convey what no longer belongs to him.” Per IGE, JCA.
FOR SUPPORT TO BARRISTERNG BLOG, DONATE TO: 1. NAIRA ACCOUNT: 1023046978 - UBA 2. USD ACCOUNT: 5090743566 - FIDELITY BANK PLC
Call Bridget Edokwe Esq on 08060798767 or send your articles to barristerngblog@gmail.com
A Must-Have for Every Lawyer: Order Justice Alaba Omolaye-Ajileye’s Latest Books on Electronic Evidence Today: To order your copies, click the link below and order directly from the author:
https://velvety-cendol-7387ed.netlify.app/
SHOP NOW
The Price is 10k for Hard Copy less freight and 5k for E- Book copy in the Store of the Website. https://buokorie.com/store/ To access the hard copy, Call - 07087622283



