The Presidential Polls, the FCT, Abuja Question And The Nigerian Constitution
Democracy is a popular system adopted by peoples that are desirous of propelling their human and nations affairs in line with their own independent yearnings and free wishes.
CONTINUE READING THIS ARTICLE BELOW AFTER THESE IMPORTANT NOTICES
Log in to primsol.lawpavilion.com and store.lawpavilion.com to enjoy the best E-journals, textbooks, and many more. For further enquiries/assistance, send an email to customercare@lawpavilion.com or call 08050298729
The basic engine through which democracy is crystalized is elections which are periodically held in every democratic country, the world over.
As a member of non dependent international community, Nigeria, having gotten political emancipation from the Britain in 1960, has, though gotten interrupted by the interregnum of the interloping military dictatorship, been on the threshold of democratic experiments.
It is the tradition that every instrument of governance and/or societal affairs is governed by set of rules, codes or laws and, in Nigeria, the chief of these rules referred to as the ground norm is the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria.
Nevertheless, it is this Constitution that specifies, regulates and determines the rights and duties of Nigerians, the powers and privileges of the governments, the creation and components of the federation and who takes what in the Nigerian electoral process, among others.
However, there has been a lingering and somewhat disturbing question over the years of the status of FCT Abuja vis a vis the components of the Federation as, currently, Nigeria is comprised of 36 components called States and Abuja.
Going back to 1976 when Federal Capital
Territory-Abuja was created by Decree No.6 of 4th February, now Cap. 503 LFN, 2004, one will decipher that by virtue of Section 1 of Decree No.6 1976 (now Cap.503), the over 9,000= sq.km of the area and constituent that is FCT-Abuja was carved out of the former States of Niger, Plateau (now Nasarawa) and Kwara (now Kogi).
From 4th February, 1976 Abuja ceased to belong or be part of the said former States, assumed a new status and become the seat of the Government of Federation.
On October 1st 1979 there was a new 1979 Constitution. Section 2(a) of the said Constitution (now 1999 Constitution) regards Nigeria as a Federation which consists of States and a Federal Capital Territory. This section, in its Subsection (4 ) further defines FCT to also be Abuja to which the provisions of Chapter VIII Part 1 thereof, consisting of sections 294 – 308, apply.
Section 297(1) defines Abuja boundaries, it’s Subsection (2) provides tthat the ownership of all lands in FCT-Abuja shall vests in the Government of the Federation while section 298 describes Abuja to be the Capital of the Federal Republic of Nigeria and seat of Government of the Federation.
In the spirit of fairness to all persons and bodies that genuinely desire knowledge of true status and position of FCT Abuja, either for academic or other purposes, understanding of Section 299 is an established sine qua non.
Section 299 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, amended 1999, provides:
“The provisions of this Constitution shall apply to the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja *as if* it were one of the States of the Federation; and accordingly-
all the legislative powers, the executive powers and the judicial powers vested in the House of Assembly, the Governor of a State shall, respectively, vest in the National Assembly, the President of the Federation and in the courts which by virtue of the foregoing provisions are courts established for the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja;
all the powers referred to in paragraph (a) of this section shall be exercised in accordance with the provisions of this Constitution; and
the provisions of this Constitution pertaining to the matters aforesaid shall be read with such modifications and adaptations as may be reasonably necessary to bring them into conformity with the provisions of this section.” (Emphasis mine).
Obviously from the above provision, one will decipher the two maverick cum ordinary words of; “…as if….”. that are subject to subjective interpretations by politicians for undue political benefits; political lawyers, probably, to justify fees, and; by others to reap the fruits of contractual/pecuniary benefits.
The respective words “as” and ‘if’ have always been the genesis of the legal uncertainties with which the provision is shrouded while the legal combination of the duo “as if” is simply the last straw that broke the camel’s back. It leaves the object of the legal construction to the mercy of speculation of being so or not so.
The celebrated case of OKOYADE vs.FCDA (2005) JELR 56722 (CA), which drew the intervention of the Supreme Court settles the question.
In this case, the Federal Capital Development Authority, FCDA, was sued in the Federal Capital Territory High Court and a question arose as to whether the FCT High Court had jurisdiction, the FCDA being the agency of the Federal Government.
This case was instituted sequel to the Supreme Court’s verdict on exposition of the jurisdiction of the Federal High Court in locus classicus case of NEPA vs. ENDEGERO (2002) LPELR-1957(SC) affecting the ‘exclusive jurisdiction’ provided by Section 251 of the Constitution in respect of cases where Federal Government or any of its agencies is a party.
For the sake of brevity, upon case sated, the Court made it abundantly clear that by virtue of Section 299 of the Constitution of the Federation, the Federal Capital Territory is, in law, a State. In others words the Federal Capital Territory should be treated as one of the States in the Federal Republic of Nigeria.
It follows therefore that bodies like the Federal Capital Development Authority are to be regarded as agency of
“a State” independent of the Federal Government.
It would appear that the only relationship that exists between the Federal Government and the Federal Capital Territory is that its executive and legislative powers and duties are exercised for it by the President through the Minister of the Federal Capital Territory and the National Assembly respectively.
In essence, from the provision of Section 299(a), where the President through the Minister of the Federal Capital Territory acts, he does so as a Governor of a State, so also where the National Assembly legislates for Abuja, it does so as a State House of Assembly.
See the cases of FAWEHINMI VS BABANGIDA (2003) 12 WRN 1; (2003) 3 NWLR (Pt. 808) page 604 where the Supreme Court endorsed the status of Federal Capital Territory as a “State” of the Federation.
Section 299 of the Constitution, having gotten the judicial imprimatur of the full panel of the Supreme Court in FAWEHINMI & ORS v. BABANGIDA & ORS (2003) LPELR-1255 (SC), has become sacrosanct in unveiling the minds of the drafters of the Nigerian constitution and making same as much a fact as the state of digestion regarding the status of Abuja as one of the Federating states. Hence, they usually state “all the States in the Federation and the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja (FCT)”, in view of the fact that FCT Abuja is wrapped with the toga of a State.
As Abuja is the 37th state, the two third constitutional requirement of 37 states is 24.6.
Nonetheless, in the case of AWOLOWO vs SHAGARI & ORS (1979) LPELR-653(SC), the Nigerian Supreme Court says though the construction of two thirds of 37 state (Abuja inclusive) as 24.6 is correct in the abstract relative to the Constitution, it is impracticable because a State is a geographical setting incapable of being divided into 24.6.
Constructively, where there are two possible meanings conveyed by the words of a statute, instrument or the Constitution, it is the most reasonable one that is usually adopted. Therefore, the one which leads to absurdity or engenders self contradiction, is jettisoned for the first and more meaningful one. This is because the framers and drafters intend no absurdity.
See the cases of:-
A-G., ABIA STATE V. A-G., FEDERATION (2002) 17 WRN 1;
(2002) 6 NWLR (Pt. 763) page 264 at 485 – 486;
O.A.U ILE-IFE V. R. A. OLIYIDE AND SONS LTD. (2001) 7 NWLR (Pt. 712) page 456 and;
AKPAN V. UMAH (2002) 23 WRN 52; (2002) 7 NWLR (PT. 767) AT 707
In other words, the term ‘each’ in the sub-section (2)(b) of Section 134 qualifies a whole State and not a fraction of a State and to interpret it otherwise is to overlook the disharmony between the word “each” and the fraction “two thirds”.
See the case of Texaco Panama Inc. v. Shell P.D.C.N. Ltd. (2002) 14 WRN 121; (2002) 5 NWLR (Pt. 759) page 209 at pages 226 – 227.
Be that as it may, in legal essence, Two-thirds of thirty-seven (37) states, to avoid any disharmony, gives 25 states.
To contend that a candidate who does not score 25% votes only in FCT Abuja out of other 36 states is not only unreasonably ludicrous but is also tantamount to placing logic on its head. This cannot be the intendment of the legislature, as the FCT cannot hold the entire nation to ransom.
Therefore, once a candidate severally polls at least 25% of votes cast in at least 25 states, whether inclusive of FCT or not, he’s won the election so long he also has the majority of the votes cast all over the Federation.Also see the cases of BAKARI V. OGUNDIPE (2021) 5 NWLR (Pt.1768) 1;
MUSA BABA-PANYA & ANOR vs. PRESIDENT-FRN & ANOR – SUIT NO. FHC/ABJ/CS/14/2015;
In the case of BABA-PANYA V. PRESIDENT, FRN (2018) 15 NWLR (Pt. 1643) 423, the Court held that the FCT, Abuja is to be treated like a State and it is not superior or inferior to any state in the Federation.
BAKARE vs. OGUNDIPE (2021) 5NWLR (pt. 1768) SC.
*What is highly significant to one of the Nigerian political parties contending otherwise here, Labour Party, which Lagos gubernatorial candidate happened to be a RHODES- VIVOUR, is the pronouncement of retired eminent jurist OLABODE RHODES- VIVOUR JSC himself delivering the lead judgment had this to say ‘on status of the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja’ as Ratio 1:-*
*By virtue of section 297(a),(b),(c) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999(as amended), the provisions of the Constitution shall apply to the Federal Capital Territory Abuja, as if it were one of the States of the Federation; and accordingly all the Legislative powers, the Executive powers and the Judicial powers vested in the House of Assembly, the Governor of a State and in the courts of a State shall respectively, vest in the National Assembly, the President of the Federation and in the courts which by virtue of the provisions are courts established for the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja; all the powers referred to in paragraph (a) of the section shall be exercised in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution; and the provisions of the Constitution pertaining to the matters aforesaid shall be read with such modifications and adaptations as may be reasonably necessary to bring them into conformity with the provisions of the section. By virtue of the provisions of section 299 of the Constitution, it is so clear that Abuja, the Federal Capital Territory of Nigeria, has the status of a State. It is as if it is one of the States of the Federation. (pp. 36-37, paras. E-A)*
Having established that Abuja, FCT is treated as a State in the Federation, it is, ipso facto, equivalent to the 37th State of the Federation.
Section 134 provides:
“A candidate for an election to the office of President shall be deemed to have been duly elected, where, there being more than two candidates for the election-
(a) He has the highest number of votes cast at the election; and
(b) He has not less than one-quarter of the votes cast at the election in each of at least two-thirds of all the States in the Federation and the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja.”
Without mincing words, nonetheless, the hulla balloo that was generated as to what determines the winner of a presidential polls in winning the majority of votes in addition to having, at least, 1/4 of votes cast in 2/3 of the states of the Federation and Abuja, undoubtedly becomes unnecessary in the face of section 134 of the Nigerian amended Constitution, 1999.
Admittedly, Abuja, being the 37th state of the Federation, does not negatively affect the victory of the Nigerian President Elect, Senator Bola Ahmed Tinubu, the winner of the February 25th Presidential polls, having been freely chosen by majority of Nigerians.
He obviously has the Constitutionally required benchmark of one fourth of the votes cast in over 2/3 of the states of the Federation and Abuja combined in 37 states.
Those bringing up arguments on media by merely playing to the gallery on this settled issue are doing so having painfully realized that their battle if taken to the Court would be a lost one, in addition to the verdict of the Court that INEC has discretion as to upload and timing of upload of results so far as what were approved and signed by parties agents were uploaded, and this is so, when collated results were compared by Nigerians after the February 25th Presidential polls.
Therefore, the real celebration and/or jubilation of electoral victory is done in a discreet and civilized way upon the swearing in of the winner when, it is obvious that the losers, being desperate at winning with the mind set of self frustration and readiness to throw away the baby with the bath water. In electioneering contests, the winner and the loser must emerge. The winner must be magnanimous and celebrate with modesty while the loser must gallantly accept defeat.
It is clear enough that Asiwaju Bola Ahmed Tinubu of APC, the President elect, aside that he has the required 1/4 of total voted cast in over 2/3 of the 37 states (Abuja inclusive), polled 8,794,726 (36.61%) to floor the first runner up, Alhaji Atiku Abubakar of PDP who polled 6,984,520 (29.07%) and the 2nd runner up Mr Peter Gregory Obi of LP who polled 6,101,533 (25.40%). He also took the lead in the following 12 states:-
EKITI – APC 201,494, LP 11,397, PDP 89,554
OGUN – APC 341,558, LP 85,829, PDP 123,831
OYO – APC 449,884, LP 99,110, PDP 182,977
KWARA – APC 263,572, LP 31,141, PDP 136,909
ONDO – APC 369,924, LP 44,405, PDP 115,463
JIGAWA – APC 421,390, LP 1,889, PDP 386,587
BENUE – APC 31O,468, LP 308,372, PDP 130,081
NIGER – APC 375,183, LP 80,452, PDP 284,898
KOGI – APC 240,751, LP 56,217, PDP 145,104
ZAMFARA – APC 298,396, LP 1,660, PDP 193,978
RIVERS – APC 231,591, LP 175,071, PDP 88,468
BORNO – APC 252,282, LP 7,205, PDP 190,921
Therefore, the querulous disposition of some political oppositions on the nature of Abuja, is sometimes, baffling, more importantly, that a simple interpretation of a simple construction becomes difficult for some political lawyers.
This is more disturbing when it is more apparent that the framers and drafters of our Constitution treat and regard FCT Abuja as a state.
It is quite needless to reephsize that just because it has no appellation as a state, FCT Abuja is referred to as “and FCT Abuja”.
Therefore, instead of saying one quarter of total votes cast in at least, 2/3 of 37 states, it says in 36 states “and Abuja” (being regarded as and equivalent to the 37th state). It is not that Abuja stands independently on its own and this is clear from the wordings of the constitution and several judicial pronouncements.
Though, whoever that is aggrieved has the right to project ahead his grievances, no matter how unreasonable or untenable for further judicial intervention and final pronouncement. But a lawyer that is worth his salt must be able to judge his case before it is judged by the judges.
BY: Prince Ahmed A. Adewoyin, LL.B, LL.M, BL BWY, CSE.
FOR SUPPORT TO BARRISTERNG BLOG, DONATE TO: 1. NAIRA ACCOUNT: 1023046978 - UBA 2. USD ACCOUNT: 5090743566 - FIDELITY BANK PLC
Call Bridget Edokwe Esq on 08060798767 or send your articles to barristerngblog@gmail.com
A Must-Have for Every Lawyer: Order Justice Alaba Omolaye-Ajileye’s Latest Books on Electronic Evidence Today: To order your copies, click the link below and order directly from the author:
https://velvety-cendol-7387ed.netlify.app/
SHOP NOW
The Price is 10k for Hard Copy less freight and 5k for E- Book copy in the Store of the Website. https://buokorie.com/store/ To access the hard copy, Call - 07087622283



